Tesla vs. Mustang EV Comparison

 

The company that made the Model T has something to say in this Model Y vs Mach E showdown of silent, speedy sport utility vehicles. The Ford Motor Company's start date precedes Elon Musk's Tesla by several decades but Tesla seems to be light years ahead of every other car company when it comes to producing high-performance electric vehicles.

However, the Ford Mustang Mach-E is a clear example that electric excellence doesn't necessarily have to come with a letter T emblazoned.

Desired changes to our atmosphere in the days ahead have the automotive industry's giants pivoting towards electric power after a history filled with gas-guzzling gluttony.

The Ford Mustang Mach-E and Tesla Model Y represent the best alternative fuel sources have to offer. Read through our comprehensive comparison on these two electric competitors below:

The Rookie and the Vet

Experience is tough to define in this comparison. While Tesla, of course, has always been plugged in, Ford is just entering the space. On the other hand, over a hundred years of producing American cars that can do it all doesn't just fall by the wayside here. Don't count Ford's experienced eye out of this Tesla Ford comparison, despite the Mach-E's lack of age.

What We Like About the Mustang Mach-E

First of all, only one of these cars is a conversation starter. While the Y struggles to differentiate itself from other Tesla models, the Mach-E doesn't look like any old Ford SUV or Mustang. You'll do a double take the first time it flies by. Whether it’s clad in eye-catching colors like Infinite Blue or Rapid Red or painted the stroke of midnight in Shadow Black, this sporty SUV stands out. If you want an electric SUV you can find easily in a crowded lot, don't settle for the same clean, white Tesla everyone already has. If you really want to make a splash, ask if your preferred trim is available in Grabber Blue or Cyber Orange. These two striking samples pack more personality into a quick glance than you'll find in a long stare at its chief competitor, which dictates your exterior color options on what year it is and how much you're willing to pay.

Aside from a wardrobe that outshines all opponents, the Mustang Mach-E provides a smoother ride as well. Thick, supportive 19-inch wheels allow you to ride smoother over various terrains and the car runs quieter and calmer than Tesla's sometimes jumpy alert system. A smooth, steady driver will enjoy handling made for gradual movements and easy adjusting that makes even cobblestone streets feel like a sandpapered path. In terms of Tesla vs Mustang's ride while you drive, the Mach-E emerges as the option that sails most sturdy, no matter how choppy the seas are.

Additionally, despite a heavier frame, the Mach-E accelerates impressively and hauls plenty. You don't lose a bunch of power by going electric and can use it well. Don't worry, we'd never write about a Mustang that can't run a quick clip.

What We Like About the Model Y

Tesla's electric-powered authority and experience shine through in a couple of key categories. First of all, minimalist styling wins out on yet another Tesla cabin as this interior is all about doing more by doing less. You'll find a ton of buttons and switches throughout the Mustang Mach-E's dashboard, configuring all sorts of climate settings and driving modes. In the Tesla, the single infotainment screen controls all. Monitor traffic conditions up further ahead, warm up cold kiddos through heated seats, operate your innovative Autopilot, and even control the direction of each air conditioning vent all with a couple of swipes of your finger. If you're all about having a car that's up to date with modern marvels sprinkled throughout, take the Tesla Model Y.

Tell Me When To Go!

To compare Model Y vs Mach E speed, it's important to first note the different trims for the Ford Mustang Mach-E.

  • Ford Mustang Mach-E Select - Starting at $42,895 MSRP1, the Select trim goes from 0 to 60 in 5.2 seconds.3
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E Premium - Starting at $47,000 MSRP1, the Premium trim accelerates to 60 mph from a standstill in just 4.8 seconds.3
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E California Route 1 - Starting at $49,800 MSRP1, the trim inspired by California's famous statelong drive accelerates to 60 mph in 6.1 seconds.3
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E First Edition - Starting at $58,800 MSRP1, the First Edition reaches 60 mph from a dead stop in 4.8 seconds.3
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E GT - Starting at $60,500 MSRP1, the GT trim leads the way by accomplishing the aforementioned feat in under four seconds.3

Each Model Y comes catered to your exact specifications through add-ons to a universal base model. That base model has a starting price of $42,190 MSRP2 when equipped with Long Range AWD.

Is the Tesla Model Y or Mustang Mach-E faster?

The Model Y can go from 0 to 60 mph in just 4.8 seconds and can reach a top speed of 135 mph when equipped with Long Range dual-motor all-wheel-drive. Choosing the Performance AWD increases the starting MSRP to $59,4902 but gives your Model Y speed capabilities the Mach-E can't catch up to. Slingshot forward as you merge into traffic in just 3.5 seconds from 0-60 mph on a rugged motor built for a top speed of 155 mph.

The Mach-E tops out with the GT trim's impressive 3.8-second "zero to 60" time and 480 horsepower on an electric all-wheel-drive setup. The GT Performance Edition targets an even quicker figure of 3.5 seconds.3 Blink and you'll miss it.

Charge Up and Head Out

So it's clear that both the Model Y and Mach E have cabin comfort worthy of piling the whole family in for a lengthy, yet ultimately fulfilling trip. Both models draw from sports car inspiration, providing plenty of speed in relative silence, free from all the trappings of traditional fossil fuel. But if you can't take the fun far away from a home charger, all of that is cut off before you can even pass "Go!"

Does the Model Y or the Mach-E have more range?

As we've mentioned in this Tesla vs. Ford piece, your Tesla Model Y comes in either Long Range or Performance all-wheel-drive. The Performance setup allows for an EPA-estimated range of 303 miles4. Not surprisingly, the Long Range setup increases your estimated range to 326 miles.

The Ford Mustang Mach-E's ranges are as follows5:

  • Ford Mustang Mach-E Select - EPA-estimated range of 230 miles
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E First Edition - EPA-estimated range of 270 miles.
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E GT - EPA-estimated range of 250 miles
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E Premium - EPA-estimated range of 300 miles
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E California Route 1 - EPA-estimated range of 305 miles

As you can see, the variety of trim options allows you to alter your Mustang Mach-E if you prioritize top-speed performance or being able to cover more miles in between fueling up.

Which crossover is better?

The Model Y vs Mach E is a worthy battle, despite the obvious gap in electric-powered experience. The Tesla Model Y drives like a distinguished older brother. It's seen it all and just wants the best for you, safe and sound inside a spotless interior that strips free all unnecessary confusion.

However, the gap here is not steep at all. Especially for being a newer entry to alternative fuel sources, particularly in luxury SUVs, the Mustang Mach-E can hold its own. It grabs your attention with a striking, memorable design and keeps it with a velvety riding experience and seats to boot. A myriad of trims allows you to pick an SUV that's catered to your specifications, whether you want a certain color, to be the fastest on the freeway, or you love skipping by the pump without worry. If you're not in love with Tesla's minimalism, we definitely encourage you to saddle up a Ford Mustang Mach-E and see how you like the next evolution in "Built Ford Tough."

Tesla Model Y: When you hear "Tesla," you already know what it is. The lofty standard in electric driving experiences has another barrier breaker in the Tesla Model Y, a fully-electric mid-size SUV with optimum acceleration. It boasts impressive estimated figures and feels like a PHEV built precisely for the future, not an altered plug-in pretender. If you want a sleek and smooth electric rough-rider speeding silently towards a more carbon-neutral future, the Tesla is a good choice.

Ford Mustang Mach-E: It's fitting that the Mustang Mach-E is going to make its debut in the summertime, as this is a car fit for sunny day drives with a sense of adventure. Five trims ensure the right electric SUV comes bursting out of your stable, you'll feel the spunky spirit of revving, wreckless abandon while actually securely safe. Nothing runs like a Mustang. Once you've held the reins, you'll be ready to ride in this luxury SUV.

Jim Ellis Ford - Frequently Asked Questions(FAQ)